Wasn't the cat's name "Jones"? But I digress.
Your idea is an interesting one, but I don't think it would work. In a film, you see and hear exactly what the filmmakers want you to, when they want you to. You're alone in a scary place, trapped with the unknown. Is that a monster around the corner, or just my imagination? Well, the monster (or one of the monsters) IS your imagination. It's your mind that transforms even the most mundane sound or environmental element into something sinister and threatening.
In a Halloween Horror Nights maze, you're walking in a line behind a thousand other people. You're certainly not alone. You hear the screams/laughs/drunken shouts from the people standing 2 feet in front of you . . . and 2 feet behind you. There is none of the intimacy that you feel while watching a movie, none of the isolation. Long periods of walking through scenes with absolutely no scareactors does not equal suspense in the way that it does in the cinema, it means there's a Cast change.
Short of a pulsed house, or even the on-your-own-style house (like Busch's Alone), you're not going to be able to achieve that suspense that's so crucial to this idea.