I'm waiting to see if Legacy will bait me a bit more with hints about the location. If I have any idea of what location we're dealing with here, I can go deeper. I'm hoping I hit something with bringing up the Colonial area, especially since he responded and said to go more east, meaning I had a decent starting point.
But I could be way off and we should actually be talking about Maine or something up there in the North East. If it does have something to do with my area, there could be a million stories coming out of a hundred areas. Since this area dates back to the beginning of our country, I would argue that we could be the most haunted part of the country. The sheer number of colonists and soliders that have died here could create an interesting story.
And I forgot all about Virginia Dare. Good job. Her area (the Outer Banks of NC) is definetly east of the Triangle, just to the south.
EDIT: Annnnd Timbo edited his post so now it looks like I'm talking to myself. He originally said "what do you it is" in the post directly before this one.